Papers · Preprint · v2

To Chart a Stone with Six Birds: Emergence Phase Diagrams for Effective Theories in Control Space

Emergence as a phase diagram.

In plain words

Sciences draw maps of where behaviors are possible: phase diagrams, stability charts, feasibility regions. Emergence is rarely treated that way.

This paper draws emergence atlases: maps over control space showing where a macro description is feasible. Feasible means closed, nontrivial, safe under audit and within budget.

Atlases are computed for law families, for all packagings of small systems, and for the PICA algebra. Rival definitions of emergence become slices of one atlas.

A table of four ways to group states 0, 1, 2 and 3, from the paper's fifteen. Designed, 0 with 1 and 2 with 3: exactly closed, an object, effective information 0.270 nats. Finest, every state apart: exactly closed, not an object, effective information 0.434 nats, the highest. One block: exactly closed, not an object. The other pairing, 0 with 2 and 1 with 3: exactly closed, not an object. Title: 15 groupings, 7 exactly closed, 1 object.
Four of the fifteen ways to group one small system, scored three ways. All four pass the closure test, only the designed grouping holds a lasting object, and a different grouping has the most effective information. Each rival definition of emergence picks out its own winner.

What it shows

  • Exact closure loci and reversible lines recovered.
  • Tradeoffs among closure, directionality, information and budget exposed.
  • A negative result in mechanism space: the earlier geometry regime and its ablation ranking are withdrawn, and a compact mechanism fails a test fixed in advance.

What it does not claim

Finite state setting only.

Cite

Tsiokos, I. (2026). To Chart a Stone with Six Birds: Emergence Phase Diagrams for Effective Theories in Control Space. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23120459