Papers · Preprint · v2

Six Birds Protocol Trap: Holonomy Without Entropy Production

Route dependence is not an arrow of time.

In plain words

Update steps that do not commute can look like time asymmetry. The paper shows how to tell them apart.

Take two kernels on three states, each reversible, that do not commute. Compare two ways of running them. First, an external controller applies one and then the other. Second, the protocol phase becomes part of the state, as a clock updated at random alongside the system.

Scheduled: a steady current around a cycle, with entropy production of about 0.0833 per step. Autonomous with an unbiased clock: zero at every horizon, even though the steps still do not commute. Bias the clock and an arrow returns, all of it coming from the clock.

Line chart of arrow of time per step against clock bias b from 0 to 0.9. A dashed curve for the clock alone rises to about 2.4; a solid curve for the whole nine-state chain is exactly half of it, with directly computed dots, reaching 0.2472 at b = 0.5 and 1.1925 at b = 0.9. At b = 0 both are zero, though the steps still do not commute.
The paper's autonomous version, with the protocol phase as a clock inside the system. With an unbiased clock there is no arrow, even though the two steps still fail to commute. Tilt the clock and an arrow appears, and all of it is the clock's own, scaled by the half of all steps that move the clock. Dots are direct calculations on the full nine-state chain.

What it shows

  • A clean null versus driven separation on a three state benchmark.
  • Holonomy and directionality decoupled.
  • For every finite stationary Markov chain, path reversal divergence over T steps is T times the entropy production rate, even when both are infinite.
  • Main theorems and exact values checked in Lean 4, with one general case argued by hand.

What it does not claim

Conclusions are for finite state discrete time kernels and the lift studied.

Cite

Tsiokos, I. (2026). Six Birds Protocol Trap: Holonomy Without Entropy Production. Zenodo. https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23120462